Passion Isn't Enough: A Practical Guide for Nonprofit Leaders

By Toni Koch

As a fundraiser deeply invested in the success of nonprofit organizations, I recently delved into David Rhode's insightful book, Passion Isn't Enough: A Practical Guide for Nonprofit Leaders for Aperio’s latest book club.

This book is a treasure trove of practical advice and strategies that resonate deeply with anyone in the nonprofit sector, especially those on the front lines of fundraising. We were fortunate to be joined by David as we explored key themes from the book through the lens of the current nonprofit landscape.

Key themes from Passion Isn’t Enough and our book club discussion with the author:

Funders have more to offer than financial support.

One of the key takeaways from David’s book is the value of cultivating meaningful partnerships with donors, regarding their role within the organization as nuanced and dynamic.

Funders should not merely steer from a mission perspective, David says, but can play a role in identifying gaps and offer resources to connect people. This approach can significantly strengthen the foundation of nonprofit organizations, making funders invaluable partners in their missions.

David’s advice on partnership development is rooted in relationship-based fundraising. He advocates for focusing on mission alignment and getting to know prospects before asking for money. This relational approach, as opposed to a transactional one, was finally when David started to see the results he was hoping to see.

One participant emphasized sharing personal connections to the mission and opening with vulnerability can ultimately foster deeper partnerships. This strategy aligns perfectly with the relational nature of fundraising, where building trust and understanding is paramount.

Board members need clarity and opportunities for engagement.

David’s insights on board management are particularly relevant for fundraisers. In the book, he highlights the common issue of unclear expectations for board members. Many individuals are passionate about the mission but unsure of their roles and responsibilities. David suggests sharing documents that outline board guidelines, expectations, and the role of the Executive Director.

The group also discussed how structured board meetings and encouraging participation are crucial for effective governance, as well as the importance of board diversity to bring fresh approaches and perspectives.  

Individual giving is essential.

As a fundraiser, I found David’s emphasis on individual giving particularly compelling. He underscores the importance of individual donations as a key source of unrestricted funds given that most of charitable giving comes from individuals.

Sharing success stories and growing donor relationships, especially through introductions from board members, can significantly enhance fundraising efforts. One participant shared an anecdote about the difficulty of getting buy-in for planned giving even in an organization that relied heavily on individual donations.

When looking to grow individual giving programs, David recommends starting with a review of existing donors and using A/B testing to see which messages can optimize engagement and donations.

You need a plan for crisis communication.

Effective crisis communication is another critical area covered in David’s book. He differentiates between existential threats and crises caused by individuals within the organization. Clear protocols on who will represent the organization and mindfulness in managing social media are vital.

The board's role in risk management and scenario planning in advance can help navigate crises more effectively. As fundraisers, being prepared for these situations ensures we can maintain donor trust and support even in challenging times.

—

Passion Isn't Enough is a must-read for nonprofit leaders and fundraisers alike. David Rhode's practical advice on funder roles, board management, fundraising, partnership development, and crisis communication among other insights provides a robust framework for building resilient and successful nonprofit organizations. For those of us dedicated to the art and science of fundraising, this book offers recommendations that can enhance our strategies and strengthen our impact.

Toni Koch

Toni’s background is in public health, and she has built a career in relationship management and fundraising for international nonprofit organizations including Rise Against Hunger, Carolina for Kibera, and Renew Oceans.